Guitar Pedal Distortion vs. Tube Amp Distortion

Guitar pedals and tube amps are both popular tools for achieving distorted guitar tones.  I would guess most people have several of both. I just counted and I have 5 distortion pedals and 3 tube amps.

There are some key differences between the two that may affect your choice of gear.  So let’s talk about guitar pedal distortion and tube amp distortion, highlighting the pros and cons of each.

Guitar Pedal Distortion

Pedals are a convenient way to achieve distorted tones without having to crank up the volume of your amp.  The is probably the biggest positive.

They are also versatile, allowing you to switch between different types of distortion with the press of a footswitch.  Pedals can sometimes sound artificial or sterile, lacking the warmth and depth of tube amp distortion.

Tube Amp Distortion

Tube amp distortion is often considered the holy grail of guitar tone. The natural compression and harmonics produced by tubes create a rich, dynamic sound that is difficult to replicate with pedals. Tube amps also respond differently to different playing styles, allowing for greater expressiveness and nuance in your playing.

So what’s the problem?  Just get tube amps, right?

Well… there you have it. Two problems with tube amps

  1. To get that amazing saturated distortion, you have to turn it up loud.
  2. Tube amps are expensive.
  3. Tube amps are heavy

Why are Tube Amps so Loud?

Tube amps  use vacuum tubes, which are able to amplify sound signals much more effectively than solid-state components. The tubes are able to produce a warmer and more natural sound, with a greater depth and dimensionality.

So, which is better? It ultimately depends on your preferences and playing style. If you’re looking for a convenient, affordable way to achieve distorted tones, pedals are a great choice. They are also useful for experimenting with different types of distortion and creating unique sounds.

If, on the other hand, you’re willing to invest in a high-quality tube amp, you’ll be rewarded with a rich, responsive sound that can take your playing to the next level. Tube amps are particularly well-suited to genres like blues and classic rock, where the subtle nuances of your playing are essential to creating an authentic sound.

Whether you prefer the convenience of pedals or the warmth of tube amps, keep experimenting until you find the gear that works best for you.

Rob Z

Got my first guitar in 1987, took lessons and played nonstop. Spent some time in hard rock and metal bands in the 1990s. I eventually switched to acoustic guitars only and rarely played for years. I got back into electric guitars when my daughter began playing in 2018. I now collect way too much gear.
Posted in